Gage & Tollner at 372 Fulton Street: Downtown Brooklyn Steakhouse Location

Gage & Tollner at 372 Fulton Street, near Smith Street, is one of New York City’s oldest restaurants, first opened in 1879 and restored to its gaslit, mahogany-paneled glory in 2021. The menu focuses on steaks, oysters, fried chicken and classic desserts.

Downtown Brooklyn has grown into a busy hub of office towers, theaters and hotels, with excellent subway access and lower prices than Manhattan. Staying nearby places the restaurant in walking distance and keeps Midtown Manhattan about twenty minutes away.

Subway Lines & Walking Distance to Fulton Street and Borough Hall in Brooklyn

The 2, 3, 4 and 5 stop at Borough Hall, about a five-minute walk from the restaurant, and the A, C and F stop at Jay Street–MetroTech, about eight minutes. The R stops at Court Street, and the B, Q and R stop at DeKalb Avenue.

From Midtown Manhattan, the 4 or 5 takes about 20 minutes to Borough Hall. Check the MTA app for weekend service changes. The B54 and B67 buses run along Jay Street and Flatbush Avenue.

Ace Hotel Brooklyn at 252 Schermerhorn Street: Stylish Hotel Near Fulton Street

The Ace Hotel Brooklyn at 252 Schermerhorn Street, at Hoyt Street, features a social lobby, a bar and rooms with vintage-inspired furniture. It sits about eight minutes on foot from Gage & Tollner.

Rates usually fall between $320 and $480. It suits couples and creative travelers who want a lively atmosphere and excellent subway access, with the A, C and G at Hoyt–Schermerhorn Streets and the 2, 3, 4 and 5 at Nevins Street.

Brooklyn Marriott at 333 Adams Street: Large Hotel at Borough Hall

The Brooklyn Marriott at 333 Adams Street, near Johnson Street, is a large full-service hotel with many room types, a restaurant and a fitness center. It sits two blocks from the courts and a short walk from the restaurant.

Sheraton Brooklyn at 228 Duffield Street: Modern Hotel Near Fulton Mall

The Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel at 228 Duffield Street, near Fulton Street, is a modern chain hotel with bright rooms and a fitness center. It sits a few blocks from the restaurant and near the.

NU Hotel Brooklyn at 85 Smith Street: Boutique Hotel in Boerum Hill

The NU Hotel Brooklyn at 85 Smith Street, between Atlantic Avenue and State Street, is a small boutique hotel with simple, modern rooms. Smith Street’s restaurants and bars are outside the door.

Steaks, Oysters & Things to Do Around Fulton Street in Downtown Brooklyn

At Gage & Tollner, order oysters, the she-crab soup, a steak or fried chicken, and finish with baked Alaska or coconut cake. The dining room is formal and atmospheric, with a long bar. Reservations are.

Best Time to Visit Downtown Brooklyn in New York City

Downtown Brooklyn is lively year-round. Spring and fall are comfortable for walking, and summer brings events and outdoor dining. Winter dinners at Gage & Tollner feel warm, with candles and gas lamps.

JFK, LaGuardia & Newark Airport to Downtown Brooklyn by Taxi and Subway

From JFK, take the AirTrain to Howard Beach and the A train to Jay Street–MetroTech, about 60 minutes. A taxi takes 35 to 60 minutes. From LaGuardia, a taxi takes about 30 to 45 minutes.

2026 NYC Hotel Nightly Rates & Booking Tips in Downtown Brooklyn

Plan on about $195 to $295 for value hotel rooms, $320 to $480 for stylish boutique hotels and $650 or more for luxury hotels in Brooklyn Heights or Manhattan. Midweek is cheaper than weekends, and.

Downtown Brooklyn Walking Routes, Fulton Mall & Brooklyn Heights Promenade

From Gage & Tollner, walk Fulton Street toward Brooklyn Borough Hall, past shops, theaters and historic commercial buildings. Brooklyn Heights is a ten-minute walk northwest, with the Promenade overlooking the Manhattan skyline.

Downtown Brooklyn Hotel Luggage, Noise & Arena Event Tips

Downtown Brooklyn hotels cater to business and event travelers, so ask about luggage storage and early check-in. Rooms facing Flatbush Avenue or Fulton Street can be noisy, so request a higher floor.

Brooklyn Dining Beyond the Steakhouse: Smith Street, Atlantic Avenue & Fort Greene

Smith Street in Boerum Hill and Cobble Hill is lined with restaurants, wine bars and bakeries. Atlantic Avenue offers Middle Eastern groceries and cafes, and Fort Greene’s DeKalb Avenue has brunch spots and casual restaurants.

Which Hotel Should You Book Near Gage & Tollner?

Choose the Ace for style, the Marriott for a large chain stay, the Sheraton for value and the NU Hotel for a quiet boutique base. All sit within walking distance of Fulton Street and the.

Common questions