Home  /  Food & drink  /  Best delis
The NYC deli & pastrami trail · 12 counters, firsthand vetted

Take a number. The pastrami’s up.

From Katz’s on East Houston Street (1888) and 2nd Ave Deli in Murray Hill to Pastrami Queen, Liebman’s in the Bronx and the Italian hero counters of the Village and Red Hook. Twelve legendary delis, what to order at each, and the hotels a few minutes’ walk away.

Matthew S. CrawfordBy Matthew S. CrawfordTravel Writer & Founder
“In New York, a great meal defines your entire trip. Never waste a single appetite on a tourist trap.”Matthew S. Crawford · The NYCHotelss Insider
Now serving00
Please take
a number

Each ticket calls one of the 12 counters. Pull again for the next.

The deli case

Twelve counters, one glass case.

Every tray has a tag. Tap one to write up its order. Use the cards on top to show only what you’re craving.

Hand-carved dailyDelicatessenEst. 1888 – today
Signature NYC institution · Est. 1888

Hand-carved hot pastrami on seeded rye.

Katz’s Delicatessen, 205 E Houston St. Pull the knife across the board. Every slice you carve gives you one thing to know before you go.

    Hot pastrami on rye at a New York deli 0 of 7 slices
    The mustard line · north to south

    One line through every counter.

    The twelve delis run from Riverdale in the Bronx down to Red Hook and Bed-Stuy in Brooklyn. Here they are in walking order, with the train for each. Copy it to your phone for the day.

      The map is a sketch for planning, not to scale.

      Next counter over

      More New York institutions.

      Hours, prices and menus change. Check with each deli before you go. Hotel links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

      The Architecture of the New York Delicatessen: Jewish Pastrami Counters and Italian Salumerias

      New York City’s sandwich culture rests on two historic immigrant pillars that evolved side by side over the past 135 years: the Eastern European Ashkenazi Jewish delicatessen—where navel beef briskets are wet-brined for up to four weeks, coated in cracked black pepper and coriander, hardwood-smoked, steamed in copper vats, and carved by hand to order—and the Southern Italian salumeria and hero shop, where imported Prosciutto di Parma, soppressata, house-pulled mozzarella, and hot roasted peppers are layered inside crusty seeded semolina loaves baked in brick ovens across Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the Bronx.

      Unlike assembly-line sandwich chains that slice cold meats on mechanical rotary blades and weigh portions on digital scales, a true New York deli counter is a theater of hand-carving skill, steam-table timing, and personal rapport between the customer and the counterman. Whether you are clutching a paper ticket at Katz’s Delicatessen (205 East Houston Street) on the Lower East Side or watching a counterman stack fried eggplant cutlets, broccoli rabe, and provolone onto an eighteen-inch hero roll at Defonte’s Sandwich Shop (379 Columbia Street) in Red Hook, understanding how each counter operates ensures you order the signature cut at the exact hour the bread and meat are at their peak.

      Complete Field Guide to All Twelve Vetted Counters on the NYCHotelss Deli Trail

      #### Manhattan Jewish Delicatessens and Old-School Sandwich Counters

      1. Katz’s Delicatessen (205 East Houston Street at Ludlow Street, Lower East Side — Est. 1888): – Subway Access: F train to 2nd Avenue (exit at the East Houston and Allen/First Avenue stairs and walk two blocks east) or F/M/J/Z to Delancey Street–Essex Street. – Nearby Hotels: The Ludlow Hotel (180 Ludlow Street, 1-minute walk), SIXTY LES (190 Allen Street, 3-minute walk), and Orchard Street Hotel (163 Orchard Street, 3-minute walk). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Hand-carved Hot Pastrami on Seeded Rye ($28.95) or Hot Corned Beef ($27.95), a Half-Sandwich and Matzo Ball Soup Combo ($28.95), a square Fried Potato Knish ($6.95), and a Dr. Brown’s Cel-Ray or Black Cherry Soda ($3.95). Every sandwich order comes with a complimentary plate of crunchy half-sour (bright green, garlic-forward, briefly brined) and full-sour (deep olive green, fermented for weeks) barrel pickles. – Counter Protocol: The moment you pass the turnstile at 205 East Houston Street, a doorman hands every single person—including children—a numbered red-and-white paper ticket. Never lose this ticket; losing it triggers a mandatory lost-ticket surcharge of $50 at the exit cashier. Skip the slow waitress-service tables along the right wall unless you want table service; instead, walk straight to one of the six active meat-carving stations. Before carving your sandwich, the cutter will slice a steaming piece of pastrami bark and hand it to you on a small paper square to taste. Drop $2 to $3 in cash into the cutter’s tip cup right then: he will ask whether you prefer lean or juicy (moist, deckle-marbled) pastrami and pile an extra two ounces of hand-cut brisket between your slices of Orwasher’s seeded rye coated in house deli mustard.

      2. 2nd Ave Deli (162 East 33rd Street between Lexington and Third Avenues in Murray Hill & 1442 First Avenue at East 75th Street on the Upper East Side — Est. 1954): – Subway Access: 6 train to 33rd Street (Park Avenue South) for the Murray Hill flagship; 6 train to 77th Street or Q train to 72nd Street for the Upper East Side outpost. – Nearby Hotels: The Shelburne Sonesta New York (303 Lexington Avenue), The Marmara Park Avenue (114 East 32nd Street), and The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel (35 East 76th Street). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Founded by Abe Lebewohl on East 10th Street in 1954 and still run by the Lebewohl family under strict kosher rabbinical supervision (meaning zero dairy—no cheese, butter, or Russian dressing made with dairy—ever enters the kitchen), 2nd Ave Deli serves Hot Pastrami or Corned Beef ($29.95), the towering Instant Heart Attack Sandwich ($34.95, pastrami or corned beef layered between two giant crispy potato latkes instead of bread), and Matzo Ball Soup ($12.95). Every meal concludes with a complimentary mini chocolate egg cream shot brought to the table with the check, alongside complimentary pickled tomatoes, coleslaw, and a dish of gribenes (crispy rendered chicken skin cracklings with caramelized onions).

      3. S&P Lunch, Formerly Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop (174 Fifth Avenue between West 22nd and West 23rd Streets, Flatiron District — Est. 1929): – Subway Access: R/W trains to 23rd Street (steps from the front door) or 6/F/M trains to 23rd Street. – Nearby Hotels: The New York EDITION (5 Madison Avenue), The Fifth Avenue Hotel (250 Fifth Avenue), and Flatiron Hotel (9 West 26th Street). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Saved and restored by Court Street Grocers partners Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, this 1929 linear chrome-stool lunch counter facing the Flatiron Building serves griddled Pastrami Reubens with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on buttery rye ($19.50), Classic Tuna Melts ($15.50), Chopped Liver and Onion on Rye ($14.50), and authentic Lime Rickeys and Chocolate Egg Creams ($5.50) pulled from vintage soda jerks. Arrive at 11:30 AM on weekdays to grab one of the red vinyl swivel stools before the Flatiron publishing and tech lunch rush hits at 12:15 PM.

      4. Pastrami Queen (1125 Lexington Avenue at East 78th Street on the Upper East Side & 138 West 72nd Street on the Upper West Side): – Subway Access: 6 train to 77th Street (Lexington Avenue) or 1/2/3/B/C trains to 72nd Street (Upper West Side). – Nearby Hotels: The Mark Hotel (25 East 77th Street), The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel (20 East 76th Street), and Hotel Beacon (2130 Broadway). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Tracing its lineage to Queens boulevard royalty in 1956 and praised by Anthony Bourdain as his personal gold standard for warm, peppery, thinly shaved kosher pastrami, Pastrami Queen serves its Hot Kosher Pastrami Sandwich ($27.95) on ultra-soft double-baked seeded rye that yields cleanly with every bite, paired with Orwasher’s Rye Toast, Garlic Dill Pickles, and Stuffed Cabbage Rolls ($18.95).

      5. Mendy’s Kosher Delicatessen (Grand Central Terminal Dining Concourse, 89 East 42nd Street & 61 East 34th Street in Murray Hill): – Subway Access: 4/5/6/7/S trains to Grand Central–42nd Street. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Glatt kosher delicatessen immortalized on Seinfeld (“Get the swordfish—no, get the soup!”), serving Hot Pastrami and Corned Beef Combos ($26.95), Beef Franks in a Blanket ($11.95), and Chicken Consommé with Matzo Balls and Kreplach ($11.95) right on the lower-level Beaux-Arts Dining Concourse for travelers boarding Metro-North or LIRR trains.

      #### Bronx and Brooklyn Jewish Delicatessen Icons

      6. Liebman’s Kosher Deli (552 West 235th Street near Johnson Avenue, Riverdale, The Bronx — Est. 1953): – Subway Access: 1 train to 238th Street (walk down the hill or take the Bx10 bus three stops west to West 235th Street and Johnson Avenue) or Metro-North Hudson Line to Spuyten Duyvil. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: At a time when the Bronx once boasted over a hundred kosher delis in the 1950s, Liebman’s stands as the borough’s last authentic mid-century kosher dining room, complete with neon window signs, green vinyl booths, and stainless-steel pickle bowls on every table. Order the Overstuffed Hot Pastrami or Brisket on Rye ($26.95), Homemade Stuffed Derma / Kishke with Brown Gravy ($11.95), Frankfurters with Baked Beans ($15.95), and a bottle of Dr. Brown’s Cream Soda ($3.50). Combine a lunch here with a morning visit to Wave Hill Public Garden and Cultural Center (4900 Independence Avenue).

      7. David’s Brisket House (533 Nostrand Avenue near Herkimer Street, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn): – Subway Access: A/C trains to Nostrand Avenue (1 block north) or LIRR to Nostrand Avenue. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: A uniquely New York culinary story: established by Romanian Jewish immigrants in the 1940s and operated since the 1970s by Yemeni Muslim proprietors who preserved the original slow-steamed kosher-style curing and carving recipes down to the exact spice rub. Their Hot Pastrami and Slow-Braised Gravy Brisket Combo on Rye ($22.95) is among the most tender, melt-in-your-mouth sandwiches in the five boroughs (halal-certified beef, cash and cards accepted, closes by 6:00 PM).

      8. Mile End Delicatessen (97A Hoyt Street between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street, Boerum Hill, Brooklyn): – Subway Access: A/C/G trains to Hoyt–Schermerhorn Streets or 2/3/4/5/B/D/N/Q/R to Atlantic Avenue–Barclays Center. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Montreal-style smoked meat delicatessen curing whole beef briskets with savory steak spices rather than sweet New York corned-beef brines. Order the Hand-Sliced Montreal Smoked Meat on Rye with Yellow Mustard ($23.00) and the Smoked Meat Poutine ($18.00) layered over cheese curds and rich beef jus.

      #### Manhattan and Brooklyn Italian Hero & Panini Institutions

      9. Faicco’s Italian Specialties (260 Bleecker Street near Cornelia Street, Greenwich Village — Est. 1900): – Subway Access: A/C/E/B/D/F/M trains to West 4th Street–Washington Square (3-minute walk west on Bleecker Street) or 1 train to Christopher Street–Stonewall. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Fourth-generation pork store and Italian salumeria famous for two-pound hero sandwiches wrapped in white butcher paper that easily feed two hungry adults. Order The Italian Hero ($22.00 — prosciutto, ham, capicola, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, oil, and red wine vinegar on a crusty hero loaf) or the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana or Pesto Hero ($21.00) alongside hot golden Rice Balls / Arancini ($6.50) stuffed with meat ragù, peas, and mozzarella. Take your sandwich two blocks to Father Demo Square or Washington Square Park.

      10. Pisillo Italian Panini (97 Nassau Street between Fulton and Ann Streets, Financial District — plus 124 West 25th Street in Chelsea): – Subway Access: 2/3/4/5/A/C/J/Z trains to Fulton Street (steps from the Nassau Street entrance). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Operated by husband-and-wife duo Carmelo Nazzaro and Franca, Pisillo imports its cured meats from Italy and bakes thirty-five numeric regional panini on brick-oven semolina bread, rustic ciabatta, or seeded whole wheat. Order the Number 23 “Pisillo” Panini ($21.00 — Prosciutto di Parma, porchetta, buffalo mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, and extra-virgin olive oil) or the Number 27 “Saporito” ($20.00 — hot soppressata, smoked mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, and spicy hot pepper spread). Note: Financial District Nassau Street is strictly cash or debit card with PIN; ask them to cut the panini in half and wrap each half separately.

      11. Alidoro (105 Sullivan Street between Prince and Spring Streets, SoHo — plus Rockefeller Center and Moynihan Train Hall outposts): – Subway Access: C/E trains to Spring Street (2-minute walk) or R/W trains to Prince Street. – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Founded on Sullivan Street in 1986, Alidoro crafts artistic Italian sandwiches free of heavy mayo or shredded iceberg lettuce, relying instead on warm Sullivan Street Bakery focaccia, truffle creams, and balsamic glazes. Order The Pinocchio ($19.50 — prosciutto, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, sweet roasted peppers, olive paste, and arugula) or The Matthew ($19.00 — Prosciutto di Parma, hot soppressata, fresh mozzarella, arugula, and dress-all-over balsamic vinaigrette).

      12. Defonte’s Sandwich Shop (379 Columbia Street at Luquer Street, Red Hook, Brooklyn — Est. 1922): – Subway Access: F/G trains to Smith–9th Streets or Carroll Street (walk 10 minutes west across the Gowanus Express underpass to Columbia Street). – 2026 Prices & Signature Order: Founded in 1922 by Sicilian immigrant Nicky Defonte to feed longshoremen working the Red Hook Erie Basin piers, this cash-friendly counter serves hot overstuffed heroes until 3:30 PM Monday through Saturday. Order the Nicky Special ($19.00 — ham, capicola, salami, fried eggplant cutlets, provolone, hot salad, lettuce, tomato, oil, and vinegar) or the Roast Beef, Fresh Mozzarella, and Fried Eggplant Hero ($20.00) dipped in warm roast beef au jus.

      Frequently Asked Questions: Best NYC Delis and Pastrami Counters

      #### What is the difference between pastrami, corned beef, and Montreal smoked meat? All three start with beef brisket, though their cuts, spice rubs, and cooking methods differ sharply. Corned beef uses the flatter “first cut” brisket, wet-cured in a salty pickling brine with mustard seeds and allspice, and is strictly boiled/steamed (never smoked). New York pastrami uses the fattier “navel” or “deckle” cut from the plate primal, wet-brined, rubbed heavily in coarse black pepper and coriander seed, hardwood-smoked to form a dark crust (“bark”), and finished in a steam box until the collagen melts. Montreal smoked meat (like at Mile End Delicatessen) is dry-cured rather than wet-brined, seasoned with savory steak spices and garlic (zero sugar), smoked, and steamed.

      #### Why can’t I order a Reuben with Swiss cheese at 2nd Ave Deli or Liebman’s? Both 2nd Ave Deli and Liebman’s Kosher Deli are strictly kosher meat restaurants operating under rabbinical supervision, which prohibits mixing meat and dairy in the same kitchen. In contrast, Katz’s Delicatessen, S&P Lunch, and Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner (548 Third Avenue) are “kosher-style” (non-kosher) delis that happily serve melted Swiss cheese, buttered rye toast, and dairy Russian dressing on their Pastrami Reubens.

      #### Does Katz’s Delicatessen accept credit cards, or is it still cash-only? While Katz’s Delicatessen was famously cash-only for well over a century, the main cashier stations near the exit and the fast-lane credit card line now accept all major credit cards, Apple Pay, and tap-to-pay alongside cash. However, you should still carry $5 in $1 bills in your pocket to tip your meat carver directly at the counter before he slices your sandwich.

      #### Can I ship Katz’s pastrami or 2nd Ave Deli matzo ball soup nationwide from my hotel? Yes. Both Katz’s Delicatessen and 2nd Ave Deli operate temperature-controlled overnight FedEx shipping programs across all 50 states, packing whole or hand-sliced vacuum-sealed pastrami by the pound, loaves of seeded rye bread, quarts of full-sour pickles, and mustard into insulated coolers.

      #### What time of day has the shortest line at Katz’s Delicatessen? On weekdays (Monday through Thursday), arrive between 9:30 AM and 11:00 AM for a late breakfast/early lunch, or between 2:45 PM and 4:45 PM in the mid-afternoon lull. On Saturdays and Sundays, the sidewalk line along East Houston and Ludlow Streets builds by 11:15 AM and stays 30 to 45 minutes deep until 3:30 PM.

      #### Where should I go for smoked salmon (lox), whitefish salad, and caviar on a bagel? In traditional New York Jewish food culture, smoked fish and cream cheese (dairy/parve) are sold at appetizing stores rather than meat delicatessens. Walk three blocks south from Katz’s Delicatessen to Russ & Daughters (179 East Houston Street between Allen and Orchard Streets; F train to 2nd Avenue, Est. 1914), pull a numbered ticket at the door, and order the Classic Gaspe Nova Smoked Salmon with Cream Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, and Capers on a Hand-Rolled Bagel ($19.00) or Super Heebster ($19.50 — whitefish and baked salmon salad with zesty dill cream cheese and wasabi flying fish roe).

      Website designed and built by Design Kreatives, a web design and SEO agency with offices in Atlanta, New York City, Washington, DC and Dubai.