Overview: Baccarat Hotel vs. The St. Regis New York

Two luxury hotels sit within a few blocks of each other in Midtown, and both are close to Fifth Avenue. The Baccarat Hotel New York is at 20 West 53rd Street, between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, next to the Museum of Modern Art. The St. Regis New York is at 2 East 55th Street, on the corner of Fifth Avenue. Both usually charge $650 or more a night. The Baccarat is modern and glittering, while the St. Regis is historic and traditional. Here is how they compare for location, rooms, service and value.

Location and Neighborhood

The Baccarat is on a quiet block of 53rd Street, right beside MoMA. You can walk to the museum in one minute, and Rockefeller Center and Saint Patrick’s Cathedral are about ten minutes away. The St. Regis sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, in the heart of the luxury shopping strip. Louis Vuitton, Tiffany and Bergdorf Goodman are all within a short walk. Both hotels are well placed for a first visit, but the Baccarat leans toward the museum and the arts, while the St. Regis leans toward shopping and the classic Fifth Avenue scene.

Getting Around by Subway

For the Baccarat, the closest trains are the E and M at Fifth Avenue–53rd Street, about a two-minute walk, and the B, D, F and M at 47th–50th Streets–Rockefeller Center. For the St. Regis, the same E and M station is two blocks south, and the N, R and W at Fifth Avenue–59th Street are a short walk north. Neither hotel is far from Grand Central, which you can reach by walking east for about fifteen minutes. With so many lines nearby, both are easy bases for getting around the city.

Rooms and Design

The Baccarat is built around crystal, with chandeliers, glass details and a bright, glamorous feel. Rooms are modern, with soft colors and luxury bedding, and many have large windows. The St. Regis is more classic, with traditional furniture, rich fabrics and a refined look that suits the building’s age. Rooms at the St. Regis are.

Food and Drink

The St. Regis is home to the King Cole Bar, known for its Maxfield Parrish mural and for the Red Snapper, which the hotel calls the original Bloody Mary. The Baccarat has its own bar and lounge areas, with a more modern mood, and it often features crystal-themed details and cocktails. For afternoon tea, both.

Service and Amenities

The St. Regis is famous for butler service, which can unpack bags, press clothes and bring coffee on request. The Baccarat has attentive staff and a spa area, and it leans toward a modern wellness experience. Both hotels have fitness facilities and concierge teams who can help with theater tickets and restaurant bookings. If personal.

Who Should Book Which

The Baccarat suits couples, design lovers and travelers who plan to visit MoMA and the surrounding museums. It also works well for guests who prefer a more modern, quieter lobby. The St. Regis suits travelers who want a historic landmark, butler service and a Fifth Avenue address. Families can stay at either hotel in a.

Prices and Booking Tips

Expect $650 or more a night at both hotels, with higher rates in October, the holiday season and during major events. The lowest prices tend to appear in late January through early March. Book a refundable rate first, and compare the final price after taxes and fees. The St. Regis is part of Marriott Bonvoy.

Arrival and Practical Tips

From JFK, a taxi to either hotel is a flat fare plus tolls and tip, usually around $90 in total. From LaGuardia, the ride is shorter. If you arrive by train at Penn Station, a taxi or the B, D, F or M from 34th Street–Herald Square to 47th–50th Streets is a simple route. Bring.

Seasons and Timing

Late spring and early fall are the easiest times to enjoy this part of Midtown, with mild weather and open-air walks between MoMA, Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center. December is magical but crowded, with long lines near the tree and the shop windows. Summer afternoons can be hot, so plan museum visits for midday and.

Which One Should You Book?

Choose the Baccarat if you want modern luxury, crystal glamour and a stay next to MoMA. Choose the St. Regis if you want a historic landmark, butler service and the famous King Cole Bar. Both hotels are excellent, and both put you in the middle of Midtown. If you are celebrating a special occasion and.

Common questions