Overview: The New York EDITION vs. The Times Square EDITION

New York has two EDITION hotels, and they share a brand but not a neighborhood. The New York EDITION is at 5 Madison Avenue, at East 24th Street, inside the old Clocktower building facing Madison Square Park. The Times Square EDITION is at 701 Seventh Avenue, at West 47th Street. Both usually charge $650 or more a night. One is a downtown design hotel. The other is a Theater District hotel with a polished feel. Here is how to choose.

Location and Neighborhood

The New York EDITION sits at Madison Square Park, in a neighborhood full of restaurants, boutiques and tree-lined streets. The Flatiron Building, Eataly and the Shake Shack in the park are a short walk away. The Times Square EDITION sits in the middle of the Theater District, a short walk from the Broadway houses and the bright lights of Times Square. The.

Getting Around by Subway

For the New York EDITION, the closest stations are the N, R and W at 23rd Street and Broadway, and the 6 at 23rd Street and Park Avenue South, both a few minutes’ walk. The F and M at 23rd Street–Sixth Avenue are within reach. For the Times Square EDITION, the N, Q, R and.

Rooms and Design

The New York EDITION has a refined, residential style, with soft colors, quality fabrics and a calm mood. Rooms are comfortable, and many have views of the park or the surrounding rooftops. The Times Square EDITION is more polished and urban, with sleek design and rooms that work well for a busy trip. Both are.

Food and Drink

The New York EDITION is known for its restaurant and bar scene, including a lobby space and rooms that occupy the lower levels of the Clocktower building, though specific venues change, so check current options. The Times Square EDITION offers dining and lounge spaces suited to pre-theater and post-show evenings. Both hotels attract local guests.

Service and Amenities

EDITION hotels are known for polished, relaxed service and design-led interiors. Staff are usually friendly and professional, and the lobbies feel like lounges rather than formal check-in halls. Both hotels offer fitness facilities and concierge help. Confirm details such as spa access, pet policies and room-service hours before you book, because they change. If you.

Who Should Book Which

The New York EDITION suits travelers who want a design-focused hotel in a neighborhood setting, close to restaurants and the park. It works well for couples and for anyone who prefers a calmer base. The Times Square EDITION suits travelers whose trip is built around Broadway, concerts and Midtown. It also works for business travelers.

Nearby Sights and What to Do

From the New York EDITION, you can walk to Madison Square Park, the Flatiron Building, Union Square and the Empire State Building. From the Times Square EDITION, you can walk to Broadway theaters, Rockefeller Center, Radio City Music Hall and Central Park. The Theater District is busiest between 6 and 8 p.m. before shows start.

Prices and Booking Tips

Plan on $650 or more a night at both hotels, with higher rates in October, the holiday season and during major events. The cheapest weeks are usually in January and February. Compare the final price after taxes and fees, and book a refundable rate first. Check for member offers through the hotel’s loyalty program, since.

Getting From the Airport

From JFK, take the AirTrain to Jamaica Station and then the E train to 34th Street–Penn Station, then take a short taxi ride to Madison Square Park, or ride the E to 50th Street for the Times Square hotel. From LaGuardia, the Q70 bus runs to Jackson Heights–Roosevelt Avenue, where the E, F, M, R.

Seasons and Timing

Madison Square Park is lovely in spring and fall. December brings holiday markets and a busy Theater District. Broadway is busiest on weekends and during school breaks. Summer can be hot, but both hotels offer cool, quiet spaces. Quiet weeks in January and February bring the best rates, and midweek stays are cheaper than weekends.

Questions Guests Ask

Guests often ask whether the two EDITIONs are alike. They share a brand style, with polished service and modern design, but they feel different because of their neighborhoods.

Which One Should You Book?

Choose the New York EDITION if you want a calm, residential luxury hotel in the Flatiron area with a strong restaurant scene. Choose the Times Square EDITION if you want a polished hotel in the middle of Broadway, with easy access to the shows and Midtown. Both are excellent, and both offer the brand’s modern.

Common questions