Via Carota (51 Grove Street): My Personal Assessment of Jody Williams & Rita Sodi’s West Village Trattoria, Insalata Verde, Cacio e Pepe & Svizzerina
Located at 51 Grove Street on Grove Street near Bleecker Street & Seventh Avenue South in West Village, Manhattan, Via Carota ($$$ ($21 Insalata Verde; $26–$32 pastas; $65–$110 per person)) is one of the defining culinary landmarks in New York City.
By Matthew S. CrawfordTravel Writer & Founder
Check live New York hotel rates
Compare nightly rates, room sizes, refundable booking options, and exact walking times to the nearest subway before locking in your stay.
Why Via Carota Holds a Special Place in My NYC Dining Assessment (By Matthew S. Crawford)
Since I started in the hospitality business back in 1998—working inside hotels, driving door-to-door in my car ringing doorbells at bed-and-breakfasts, and registering and building my state hotel domain conglomerate including CaliforniaHotels.com (January 10, 1998), and many more state hotel domains under MSCrawford Group, Inc. before selling the portfolio to First Internet Travel, which subsequently sold it to Cendant Corporation—I have dined in and evaluated the finest restaurants and hotels across more than 40 countries on five continents. Growing up on Long Island and spending decades at New York City’s most iconic tables, I always tell travelers that a great New York restaurant is defined by three things: unmistakable architectural character, dishes and drinks that hit the mark every single time, and a front-of-house team that treats every guest with genuine pride.
Established in 2014 (James Beard Best Chefs in America Winners Jody Williams (Buvette) and Rita Sodi (I Sodi)), Via Carota has anchored West Village, Manhattan as a benchmark for Beloved West Village Florentine Trattoria (Winner of James Beard Best Chefs in America) in New York City. Staying at the pinnacle of New York City’s culinary landscape requires daily dedication from the executive chefs, sommeliers, captains, and floor staff. Whether you are booking a table for a special celebration or stopping into West Village, Manhattan for a favorite neighborhood plate, the atmosphere at 51 Grove Street (between Bleecker & Seventh Avenue South) reflects decades of genuine New York hospitality.
How the Dining Room Works: The House Ritual at Via Carota
The House Ritual at 51 Grove Street: Named after the street in the Tuscan hills outside Florence where Jody Williams and Rita Sodi lived, Via Carota’s weathered wood tables, antique sideboards, and chipped marble plates host everyone from Taylor Swift to neighborhood regulars—and every single table orders the towering mound of Insalata Verde.
Understanding that rhythm before you walk through the doors on Grove Street near Bleecker Street & Seventh Avenue South lets you relax immediately into the evening and enjoy the craftsmanship of the kitchen, sommeliers, and dining room captains.
Find your New York hotel
Pick a neighborhood or hotel style and compare live NYC rates
Via Carota Menu & Prices: Signature Dishes to Order
When dining at Via Carota ($$$ ($21 Insalata Verde; $26–$32 pastas; $65–$110 per person)), build your meal around these verified house specialties:
Reservations, Operating Hours, Payment Policy & Dress Code
Subway Directions & Best Hotels Near Via Carota on Grove Street
At NYCHOTELSS.COM (“The Extra S Is For Savings”), pairing an unforgettable dinner reservation at Via Carota with a five-star or boutique hotel within walking distance makes your entire New York evening effortless:
Subway & Transit Arrival: Direct MTA express and local subway access within a two-to-four-minute walk of 51 Grove Street (Grove Street near Bleecker Street & Seventh Avenue South).
For a complete block-by-block hotel comparison around 51 Grove Street, read our companion guide to Hotels Near Via Carota on Grove Street Near Bleecker Street & Seventh Avenue South.
NYC Culinary & Hospitality Comparison: italian american · rich torrisi · new york ny
When planning an evening around Via Carota at 51 Grove Street (Grove Street near Bleecker Street & Seventh Avenue South) in West Village, Manhattan, discerning diners and hotel guests evaluate torrisi italian specialties, italian american cuisine, italian american, parmesan cheese, vodka rigatoni, rich torrisi, reservations, new york ny, restaurants, reservation, restaurant, mozzarella. Across New York City’s classic and Michelin-starred dining rooms, knowing how the bar, main dining room, and reservation release calendar operate ensures a seamless experience from your first cocktail to dessert.
Essential Dining Room & Neighborhood Notes (red sauce)
In our firsthand assessments for NYCHOTELSS.COM (“The Extra S Is For Savings”), guests visiting Via Carota also compare veal parm, delicious, red sauce, locations, celebrate, parmesan, rigatoni, recently, elevated, favorite, italian, carbone alongside quality, servers, thought, cheese, sauces, eating, sunday, paying, prices, server, sauce, posts, pairing a world-class table on Grove Street with a five-star or boutique stay within walking distance.
Common questions about Via Carota
QWhere is Via Carota located in New York City?
QWhat is Via Carota most famous for on the menu?
QWhich subway lines are closest to Via Carota?
QWhere should I stay near Via Carota?
Matthew’s picks nearby on the food map
Six more real places from the NYCHotelss food directory that fit this guide, each with the closest hotel. Save any of them to your trip.
Carbone
Greenwich Village · 181 Thompson St, ManhattanMid-century New York Italian-American supper club famous for spicy rigatoni vodka, tableside Caesar, and veal parmesan.
Marea
Central Park SouthItalian seafood and handmade pasta near Columbus Circle.
Lilia
Williamsburg, BrooklynHandmade pastas and wood-fired dishes in a former auto body shop.
Don Angie
West Village / Meatpacking DistrictItalian-American favorites, famous for stuffed garlic flatbread.
Locanda Verde
Tribeca / SoHo / ChinatownItalian comfort food at the Greenwich Hotel.
Il Mulino
Midtown East / Sutton PlaceA long-running Village Italian institution.
Every hotel on this page, with the real price
The hotels named above, in one place. Type a nightly rate to see the all-in price with New York’s 14.75% tax and $3.50 a night, then save the ones you like.
The Mark
Upper East SideWalker Hotel
Union SquareGansevoort Meatpacking NYC
Meatpacking DistrictKeep reading
NYCHotelss.com earns a commission when you check rates or book through our Booking.com links, at no extra cost to you.
Author photo background: Cooper’s Beach, Southampton, by Alberto-g-rovi, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Inside Via Carota at 51 Grove Street: How Jody Williams and Rita Sodi Built the Ultimate West Village Trattoria
Opened in November 2014 at 51 Grove Street (between Bleecker Street and Seventh Avenue South, West Village, New York, NY 10014) by life and culinary partners Jody Williams (founder of the Parisian gastrothèque Buvette right across the street at 42 Grove Street) and Rita Sodi (chef-owner of Tuscan powerhouse I Sodi around the corner at 314 Bleecker Street), Via Carota takes its name from the country road in the hills outside Florence where the two chefs once shared a home. In 2019, Williams and Sodi won the James Beard Foundation Award for Best Chefs in New York City, and over the past decade their weathered-wood dining room—outfitted with 17th-century chapel floorboards, antique Italian apothecary cabinets, chipped porcelain plates, and heavy water tumblers—has become the single most beloved neighborhood table in Manhattan.
Step-by-Step Walk-In Strategy: How to Put Your Name Down and Wait at Bar Pisellino
Because around 75% of Via Carota’s tables are held strictly for walk-in guests every day (with only a small number of Resy tables released 30 days ahead at midnight), the secret to dining here without frustration is mastering the Grove Street Host Stand & Bar Pisellino Routine: 1. Continuous Kitchen Hours (11:00 AM to 11:00 PM Daily): Unlike most West Village restaurants that close between lunch and dinner, Via Carota serves its full menu continuously from 11:00 AM until 11:00 PM seven days a week. 2. Best Walk-In Windows (Zero or 15-Minute Wait): Walk up to the host podium outside 51 Grove Street between 11:00 AM and 11:45 AM for early lunch, or between 2:30 PM and 4:45 PM on a weekday afternoon. You will often be seated immediately at a marble or timber table! 3. Prime Dinner Wait Strategy (5:30 PM to 9:00 PM): If you arrive at 6:00 PM on a Friday and the host quotes a 90-to-120-minute wait, give your cell phone number and walk literally 40 feet across the street to 52 Grove Street (at Seventh Avenue South) to Bar Pisellino—Williams and Sodi’s jewel-box Italian aperitivo bar! Order a Negroni Sbagliato ($18), Aperol Spritz ($17), or Via Carota Craft Bottled Old Fashioned ($18) with warm Castelvetrano olives on the sidewalk until your text message buzzes that your table at 51 Grove Street is ready.
2026 Via Carota Menu & Price Guide: Dish-by-Dish Breakdown
The menu at 51 Grove Street is organized the traditional Tuscan way—Verdure (Vegetables), Primi (Pastas), Secondi (Meats & Fish), and Contorni—designed so two to four guests can share five or six plates down the center of the table: Insalata Verde ($21 — Mandatory on Every Table): A towering, architectural mountain of hand-torn butterhead, curly endive, oak leaf, watercress, and frisée lettuces dressed to the final millimeter in aged sherry-shallot vinaigrette with parmigiano. Even self-proclaimed carnivores call it the best green salad in New York City. Verdure & Antipasti ($16 to $26): Carciofi alla Romana / Fried Artichokes ($24): Crispy whole baby artichokes with garlic, mint, and lemon. Fried Rabbit ($25): Crisp, golden herb-roasted morsels of rabbit with whole roasted garlic cloves and rosemary. Polpo ($26): Grilled charred octopus over warm gigante white beans and Tuscan olive oil. Fritto Misto ($24) & Steamed Mussels with Grilled Country Bread ($23). Handmade Primi Pastas ($26 to $32): Tonnarelli Cacio e Pepe ($27): Thick, chewy guitar-string tonnarelli pasta emulsified in toasted cracked black pepper and aged Pecorino Romano cheese until glossy. Pappardelle with Wild Boar Ragù ($30): Wide ribbons of fresh egg pasta tossed in slow-braised Tuscan wild boar. Tagliolini ($28) & Risotto of the Day ($29–$32). The Legendary Svizzerina ($29) & Secondi: Svizzerina (Tuscan Hand-Chopped Steak Burger — $29): Named after the Swiss butchers of Florence, this bunless, coarse-chopped prime ribeye and strip steak patty is seared medium-rare over the grill with rosemary, garlic, and cracked pepper, resting in a pool of Tuscan olive oil and meat juices (order grilled country bread to soak up the pan juices!). * Arista ($34): Tuscan garlic-and-rosemary roasted pork loin chop.
Subway Directions and Best Hotels Near 51 Grove Street
Closest Subway Stations: Christopher Street–Stonewall Station (1 Train at Seventh Avenue South & Grove/Christopher Streets) is literally 60 seconds on foot from the front door! West 4th Street–Washington Square Station (A, B, C, D, E, F, and M Trains) is a 4-minute walk southeast along Grove and Barrow Streets. Best Nearby Hotels (With 2026 Rates Before 14.75% + $3.50/Night Tax): Walker Hotel Greenwich Village (52 West 13th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, New York, NY 10011): Nine minutes northeast on foot ($365 to $565/night). Washington Square Hotel (103 Waverly Place at MacDougal Street, New York, NY 10011): Five minutes east across Seventh Avenue South ($315 to $495/night). * Gansevoort Meatpacking NYC (18 Ninth Avenue at West 13th Street) & The Standard, High Line (848 Washington Street): Ten minutes northwest on foot ($445 to $795/night).
Additional Frequently Asked Questions: Dining at Via Carota
Can I book Via Carota on Resy, or is it walk-in only?
Via Carota releases a limited batch of lunch and dinner reservations on Resy exactly 30 days in advance at 12:00 AM (midnight) Eastern Time, which typically vanish within 10 seconds. However, because 75% of the dining room and all outdoor sidewalk tables on Grove Street are saved for walk-ins, you never need a reservation if you arrive at 11:00 AM, between 2:30 PM and 4:45 PM, or put your name down at 5:30 PM.
What is the difference between Via Carota, I Sodi, Buvette, and Bar Pisellino?
All four sit within 200 feet of each other on Grove and Bleecker Streets under Jody Williams and Rita Sodi! Via Carota (51 Grove Street) is the rustic all-day Florentine trattoria; I Sodi (314 Bleecker Street) is Rita Sodi’s quieter evening Tuscan dining room famous for 16-layer lasagna and Negronis; Buvette (42 Grove Street) is Jody Williams’s Parisian breakfast-to-late-night café (famous for steamed eggs, croque madame, and chocolate mousse); and Bar Pisellino (52 Grove Street) is their corner Italian espresso and aperitivo bar.
Does Via Carota have outdoor seating on Grove Street?
Yes, Via Carota sets out shaded sidewalk bistro tables and a covered outdoor dining structure along leafy Grove Street between Bleecker Street and Seventh Avenue South, all assigned first-come, first-served through the walk-in host podium.
What should two first-time diners order to share at Via Carota?
For the quintessential table for two, order the Insalata Verde ($21), Fried Artichokes or Fried Rabbit ($24–$25), Tonnarelli Cacio e Pepe ($27), and the Svizzerina hand-chopped steak with grilled country bread ($29), paired with two glasses of Chianti Classico or a bottled Negroni.

My New York trip
0 saved · NYCHotelss.comYour list stays saved in this browser on every NYCHotelss page, so it’s here when you come back. Rates are typical starting rates; live prices appear when you check rates.